Tag 9/11

The Last 9/11 Post I Hope I’ll Ever Write

It’s time to give it over to history once and for all. There’s no question that the aftermath has long since overshadowed the tragedy itself. It is the aftermath that has reshaped the world in its twisted and destructive grasp. We’ve long ago stopped even pretending to be interested in the lives lost and lives disrupted. The power elite found every possible avenue of exploitation — political, economic, social — and have ruined anything and everything in their efforts to wring every last ounce of worth from them. And with the reality wiped away by the iconography and ideology, we can safely let it go. The whirlwind it created is now permanently self-sustaining without it.

I am done with the media’s ghoulish obsession, but I have come across three things to share:

Noted economist Joseph Stiglitz writes about “The Price of 9/11″ at Project Syndicate.org, and concludes that his original estimate of the “real” cost of 9/11 at $3-5 trillion is probably off by 50% as the decade-long wars drag on, destroying our economy in the process.

Much of that cost can be found in the Village Voice’s story “9/11: The Winners”, written by Graham Rayman, which looks at the widespread profiteering on the part of private individuals, unprincipled business people and government officials who all found a way to cash in one way or another.

And Gawker’s John Cook says “Thanks, 9/11!” for a whole laundry list of things that would have been almost unimaginable ten years ago.

Personally, I don’t want to write, read, hear or watch anything more about it for a long, long time. May the people who were truly affected by the tragedy someday have their peace if they have yet to find it, and may we all find a way to move along.

EmailStumbleUponRedditFacebookTwitterGoogle+Share

Related Posts:

Remember Them

EmailStumbleUponRedditFacebookTwitterGoogle+Share

Related Posts:

Putting Mumbai Into Context

It seemed that, within only a few hours into the several days it took for the terrorist attacks in Mumbai to play out, the news media had already dubbed it “India’s 9/11″. Not just the typically overwrought American news organizations, but the Indian media itself, and even such normally non-sensationlist outlets as the BBC rushed to brand the event with that still-portentious label.

The trouble is that the parallels are very few between the two incidents except for what appears to be a lot of time spent planning the details and also the clever subversion of the in-place security systems against themselves to give the attackers quick and easy access to their targets. Equally troubling, at least to me, is that though political violence is not the least bit uncommon in India, usually resulting in many more deaths than the 180-odd victims in Mumbai, the Western media in particular couldn’t seem to give a rat’s ass about the struggle between Muslims and Hindus in India until it affected rich, white American tourists staying in one of the poshest hotels in the world. As soon as some of the released hostages started telling the press that the attackers were singling out Americans and Britons, this went from being a story covered in the “also today” part of the news to being Story Number One, complete with live updates and all the fancy newsgraphics you could handle.

Because Mumbai is a media capital, complete with the world’s largest film industry, money, power, and the people who control both are familiar sights there than they are in Delhi or other Indian cities (except possibly for the outsourcing hub of Bangalore). Jeopardize a few blond-haired-blue-eyed people with well-lined pockets and suddenly you’ve got the latest chapter in The War Against Terror. This also just happens to be perfect fodder for the outgoing Bush people AND the incoming Obama people, all of whom can posture as much as they like without actually having to do anything except issue “statements of condemnation”. America LOVES terrorist attacks when they happen somewhere else! We didn’t even have to interrupt the Thanksgiving football games for those annoying “Special Reports”.

Writing in the New York Times on Tuesday, Indian novelist Amitav Ghosh talks about the important distinctions between 9/11 and Mumbai and also explores his memories about the violence in India in 1984 over Punjab separatists and Kashmir, which resulted in the massacre of over 2000 Sikhs and the assassination of Indira Gandhi. The scope of political violence in India, he says, makes the Mumbai attacks seem relatively minor within India, and he compares the incident more to the Madrid railway bombing of 2004. Resultingly, he says, he thinks the official response by the Indian government should be more aligned with the efforts in Europe that treated the incident as a criminal investigation than the Grand Guignol of 9/11.

Writing in The Nation, contributing writer Lakshmi Chaudhry similarly finds little on-the-ground rationale for making the 9/11 comparison. She also talks about the rush on the part of many to wrap Mumbai up in the web of The War Against Terror, as yet another battlefield in the struggle between God-Blessed America and the Muslim Evildoer Bin Laden, rather than an incident that is almost completely explicable within the framework of long-standing Indian internal strife. She points out that the struggle to frame the incident isn’t even over, as now in the aftermath there is much debate about who the terrorists were, who supported them, and what their larger objectives were. Ultimately, though, she concludes that the enduring symbolism of 9/11 provides a framework for any group which finds itself victimized by terror to explain their grief to the world in a way that they connect with. The danger is in letting the power of the idea outweigh the reality of the situation.

EmailStumbleUponRedditFacebookTwitterGoogle+Share

Related Posts:

Rant & Rave, Part II: Remembering September 11

Keith Olbermann got pretty steamed last week when the RNC chose to show video footage from the events of 9/11; he apologized on air and the next morning made it clear that he would have one of his “Special Comment” rants about it on his show this week. Last night (or early this morning, if you want to be picky about it) he delivered:

I think he got a little carried away with the part about McCain personally abetting Osama Bin Laden by not revealing his “secret plan”, but his primary point — that the Republicans have shamelessly and cynically used the events of 9/11 not just at the convention but for the last seven years as a weapon of fear and distraction to further their misdeeds and malfeasance — is unassailably spot-on. It goes beyond the shame that the Republican Party should bear for fetishizing those images last week, it is absolutely nothing short of sedition. Keith Olbermann may play the outrage card a little more often than is really necessary, but his outrage now is wholly justified.

Since 2002, the New York skyline has been highlighted several times with the “Tribute In Light” display of two shafts of light shooting straight up into the sky from so-called “Ground Zero”. This year, as for the last two, the display will be visible only for the anniversary, and there are presently no plans to bring it back, since the construction work on the new buildings in that spot continues apace. As a memorial, it has been simple and dignified, but the continued exploitation of “Ground Zero” as a tourist destination cheapens any serious remebrance, and Olbermann’s commentary demonstrates that this coarsening of what was for many a personal tragedy seems to know no limit.

Writing at The Seminal, contributor “Red Wing” adds his thoughts and observations to the pornification of September 11, echoing some of the same sentiment expressed by Olbermann. How long indeed before this anniversary is turned into a three-day weekend, complete with shopping mall sales, car dealer “discount events”, and college football extravaganzas?

Finally, while John McCain and Barack Obama waste our time and insult our intelligence arguing about the phrase “putting lipstick on a pig”, Democratic Congressman Dennis Kucinich continues to fight to keep alive the calls for accountability for the tragedy of September 11, 2001. Writing in “The Nation” this week, Representative Kucinich says he will ask Congress to create a “Truth and Reconciliation” commission to once and for all bring to light a complete and accurate picture of the deceptions of the Bush Administration after 9/11, as well as their deliberate ignorance of events before 9/11, and to begin a national dialogue to find a path to reconciliation between the sharply-divided factions of the American public. I offer you the following excerpts, but recommend reading the entire piece:

We suffer in our remembrance of 9/11, because of the terrible loss of innocent lives on that grim day. We also suffer because 9/11 was seized as an opportunity to run a political agenda, which has set America on a course of the destruction of another nation and the destruction of our own Constitution. And we have become less secure as a result of the warped practice of pursing peace through the exercise of pre-emptive military strength.

It is not simply 9/11 that needs to be remembered. We also need to remember the politicization of 9/11 and the polarizing narrative which followed, locking us into endless conflict, a war on terror which has wrought further terror worldwide and which has severely damaged our standing worldwide as an honorable, compassionate nation. As we were all victims of 9/11, so we have become victims of the interpretation of 9/11.

…The dominant color of our new national security since 911 is neither red, white nor blue. Every day is orange. Every day, reminders of fear of 9/11 become banal. Yet we no longer hear the airport announcements nor see the orange-colored warnings because they have commonplace standards in our new national security state, as is the Patriot Act, wiretapping, and a host of invasions of privacy and diminution of civil liberties. The Constitution has been roundly attacked by the very people who took an oath to defend it.

…our path may necessarily be different: High US government officials stand accused in impeachment petitions of violating national and international law. Our continued existence as a democracy may depend upon how thoroughly we seek the truth. I will call upon the America people to join me in supporting this effort.

The truth can move us forward, as a unified whole, so that we can one day become a re-United States. 9/11 is the day the world changed. It is the day America embraced a metaphor of war. If we are open to truth and reconciliation, we may one day be able, once again, to embrace peace.

Peace be with all of the victims of the horrific events of September 11, 2001, dead and alive, near and far.

EmailStumbleUponRedditFacebookTwitterGoogle+Share

Related Posts:

Forget What?

If you approached a group of random strangers and asked them what year the September 11 terrorist attacks took place, how many people do you think would answer the question correctly.

This interviewer got ONE correct answer.

So much for all those bumper stickers and tattered little flags flying from the backs of your cars, folks.

EmailStumbleUponRedditFacebookTwitterGoogle+Share

Related Posts:

Suckiversaries

Giuliani for 9/11

Well, I think I finally figured out why Alberto Gonzales chose this past Monday to quit — it’s because he knew that the story would be buried under all the pre-planned media coverage of the anniversary of Hurricane Katrina and the anniversary of the death of Princess Diana. Even though the Katrina coverage doesn’t make the Bushies look very good, Gonzo doesn’t figure into the story, so there’s been no added ignominy on top of the usual amount of lying and deceit he’s come to be known for. Then, the whole Larry Craig thing was just a bonus.

The media, for their part, love these anniversary things because they can plan them out so far in advance. NBC in particular has spent all friggin’ summer cueing up “Candle In The Wind”, and today they’re even replaying the entire coverage of Diana’s funeral all morning long. And if I see one more Today Show piece about the princes, I’m gonna plotz. The problem for the news media in staging anniversary programming for Hurrican Katrina is that the story isn’t really over. They hate stories that don’t have closure, particularly if they don’t have tidy endings, and New Orleans is anything BUT a tidy ending. So they focus on showing archival footage, since we love to watch disasters, and they root out the happy-ending stories as best they can like truffling-sniffing pigs.

Of course, the Mack Daddy of Suckiversaries is only a few days away now. People just aren’t afraid enough anymore, apparently, since one of the latest memes to come out of the right-wing groupmind is that “we need another attack like 9/11 to put some sense into people”. (Now THERE’S a constructive thought.) But 9/11 is about the only thing the Republicans have left (heck, it’s the only thing Rudy Giuliani actually ever had in the first place), and they’ll be chanting that mantra non-stop just as soon as they get Larry Craig to quit. The left-wing groupmind at Daily Kos has even managed to convince themselves that Bush will use this 9/11 anniversary as the launching pad to start his war with Iran (personally, I seriously doubt it).

Suckiversaries don’t help anybody. It’s like picking an almost-healed scab just to see if it will still bleed. In the case of Princess Diana, the utter shamelessness of raping her corpse over and over again for the last possible shred of public interest has really hit a new low. Katrina and the destruction of New Orleans never should have faded from our attention in the first place — the media’s shame pales in comparison to the shame owned by every person in this country. As far as September 11, now that it’s obvious that there isn’t a bomb-throwing terrorist behind every lamp post in America, the time has come to stop with the fear-mongering, to simply pay respect to the people who died, and to move beyond.

EmailStumbleUponRedditFacebookTwitterGoogle+Share

Related Posts:

What A Co-inky-dink!

Crew of the Enola Gay

PDB August 6, 2001

You know how some dates just seem to have historical resonance? Like how April 20 (Hitler’s birthday) also coincides with the Columbine Massacre and the Oklahoma City bombing (April 19, 1995).

Today we have a similar set of unrelated but significant historical observances: first, we mark the 62nd anniversary of the dropping of the first atomic bomb, which destroyed Hiroshima and ushered in the Nuclear Age. Second, today is the sixth anniversary of the infamous Presidential Daily Briefing (note: link goes to a PDF) in which George W. Bush was alerted that Osama Bin Laden was planning an attack on New York City in early September, but chose to ignore the briefing and go fishing at his Crawford ranch instead, ushering in the Age of Fascist America.

Let’s hope the two don’t somehow get mashed up for some future August 6.

EmailStumbleUponRedditFacebookTwitterGoogle+Share

Related Posts:

Indelible Images

overnyc.jpg

This great photo of Manhattan as seen from an airliner on its landing approach comes from the blog of another mutual Friend of Torrez, a fellow I only know as “Vidiot”. Here’s a larger version of the picture on his photo blog.

As I said on the flickr page for this picture, when I used to fly back and forth to New York on the Delta/USAir shuttles, my favorite part of the flight was when the landing approach took us directly over Manhattan like this, getting lower and lower past the skyscrapers as the plane made it’s last big turn over the southern tip of Manhattan.

I stopped making that regular trip to New York in 1999 and didn’t fly into New York again for several years, during which time the world changed drastically. Apparently it’s possible once again to have this view flying into the city, but I personally can’t help but think of 9/11 and the people on those planes that morning, flying the same route. Vidiot pointed me to this 2003 Salon “Ask The Pilot” column, where the columnist, Patrick Smith (a former airline pilot) talks about his own impressions of flying this approach.

(Oh, and Vidiot also makes a mean pot of chicken stock)

EmailStumbleUponRedditFacebookTwitterGoogle+Share

Related Posts:

All Original Content Copyright © BrianKaneOnline
All Other Content Copyright © Its Original Authors

Built on Notes Blog Core
Powered by WordPress

Switch to our mobile site